The Pros and Cons of Joining in a Discourse Community

Ain’t Nobody Messin’ With My Clique

Two people, one language, one communication path. This is what we would define as a discourse community. While Dr. Tripp easily defined this for us, Ann Johns spent a good time dwelling on this fact of what a discourse community is. In her essay, “Discourse Communities and Communities of Practice: Membership, Conflict, and Diversity” Johns breaks down discourse communities in many ways. Certain discussions touching on points of being involved in different groups reminded me a lot of my college experiences.

“As this discussion indicates, individuals often affiliate with several communities at the same time, with varying levels of involvement and interest” (502). Johns makes it a point to get the reader to understand that you may be a part of a group because of agreement on certain topics, and as time goes on, the group can evolve and that might change your level of involvement. When I first rushed Pi Phi, I was barely involved at all.

I never came around, and in reality, that was because I really didn’t understand anything that was going on. On top of Pi Phi, I had a job, school, and many other groups | was involved in. I also sign up for way too many things at the same time, so there is no way I can be heavily involved in all these different discourse communities. As time went on, things evolved and my views and involvement level changed between my different groups. I went from being heavily involved in work and other things to being mostly involved in Pi Phi and school.

Get quality help now

KarrieWrites

Verified

Proficient in: Discourse Community

5 (339)

“ KarrieWrites did such a phenomenal job on this assignment! He completed it prior to its deadline and was thorough and informative. ”

+84 relevant experts are online

Hire writer

To this day, things still change, but I’m mostly involved in the same things. This proves Johns point of joining and involvement.

Alongside, she provides us with a conflict brought up in joining a discourse community and staying involved. As a personal choice, you choose to join and stay involved for you. I joined Pi Phi because I personally wanted to be in a sorority. Yes, it was my choice how involved I got, and I’m glad I did. Throughout rush, I started to realize how picky they could be. Johns’ states, “In some cases people are excluded from communities because they lack social standing, talent, or money, or because they live in the wrong part of town” (511). I now understand how mean these sororities can be when cutting girls because of reasons just like this. The one comment she made that related most to my Pi Phi experience was the case where a “community membership requires a long initiatory process, and even then there is no guarantee of success” (511). Pi Phi and every sorority require a long initiation process to become a sister. Even being a sister, there can still be cliques within the sorority that can separate them from the entire group. With a discourse community like this you see many positive and negative aspects; many group bonding experiences, but also many conflicts. No discourse community is perfect, but depending on how involved you are will depend on your standing and view on that group. Being in many groups can show you the differences in being involved in different discourse communities. These communities “are useful to study because they can share conventions, values, and histories” (516).