Cinderella Critique by Catherine Orenstein and Peg Streep

As children we have all heard the story of Cinderella many times before. In this story we are enchanted by a magical idea that fairy tales exist, true love is real, and that there is such a thing as a happy ending. Two authors, Catherine Orenstein and Peg Streep, both write articles based off of the story of Cinderella and what they believe are the true hidden meanings behind the story. The article “Why the story of Cinderella Still Enchants” by Peg Streep is more focused on the happily ever after ending than Catherine Orenstein’s article “Fairy Tales and a Dose of Reality”.

Orenstein thinks people have made Cinderella into a reality fairy tale that is not so much based on true love but more on the false appearance that there is one.

Critique of Cinderella as a Love Story

Many people when they were children heard of “Cinderella” as long with many other children stories. It sparked their imaginations and their beliefs in fairy tales.

Some children did grow out of the true love fairy tale and some grew up to still believe in it. Orenstein’s article exceeds all the childish magic, unlike Streep’s article. Orenstein says the story has blinded many in the hopes of looking for a fairy tale love, and they focus too much on the reality of true love and happily ever after’s. However, Streep’s article states that “Cinderella” is a story that children fall back on whenever they feel left out.

Get quality help now

Bella Hamilton

Verified

Proficient in: Books

5 (234)

“ Very organized ,I enjoyed and Loved every bit of our professional interaction ”

+84 relevant experts are online

Hire writer

It is a story that is relatable to the child’s emotions. The children will see that Cinderella is unwanted and underappreciated but that she then gets what she wishes for all thanks to magic. Both authors give more of their opinions than actual facts on how people were truly affected by the “Cinderella” story.

Orenstein concentrates on reality television bringing up our childhood fairy tales and how they use illusions on try to portray our fairy tale fantasies in real life. She uses shows such as “The Bachelorette,” “Married by America,” and “Th…