Shaming is not an exact representation of everybody but rather a piece of everybody. The stories by Jon Ronson How One Stupid Tweet Blew Up Justine Saccos Life and Jennifer Jacquets From Is Shaming Necessary? conveys a message about shaming. How One Stupid Tweet Blew Up Justine Saccos Life examines much more on the effects of shaming than that of From Is Shaming Necessary? because it explains how shaming could be useful in certain ways. Both of these stories lay down a strong foundation of self-proclamation, hypocrisy, and wakefulness which further entails that life is shaped upon the words of one another.
Jon Ronsons How One Stupid Tweet Blew Up Justine Saccos Life follows a particular time of Justines life and how she came upon the wrath of online people. The online goers have her hell because of the tweet she sent saying, Going to Africa. Hope I dont get AIDS. Just kidding. Im white! (Ronson 81).
This set forth a blazing path that will possibly haunt her for the rest of her life and cause her to think before saying. She did not realize how much hate she received from that tweet because she was on a flight, but when she landed a rush of pings came about and stormed her with negative reactions toward her and the tweet. The shame she received was quite a lot for one to handle and somehow manage through it. Being known as the girl who tweeted something edgy and of controversial matters, these reactions left her with a forever wound.
Her life was changed drastically because of that one tweet, so it shows that one should not speak sporadically. Now, the author does not believe that she deserved all the hate that had come with the tweet but rather felt sorry for her because he felt that no one should be shamed irrationally. Let it be known that life does not only revolve around a single person and that there is this whole earth surrounding everyone.
Jennifer Jacquets From Is Shaming Necessary? tells about examples of public shaming and how shaming could be used for the greater good. An example explains how a Texas man filmed his neighbor doing an illegal act and later publicly posted it with an intent to help him in his case against the offender. The Texas man was posting it to publicly shame the offender but also just wanting an extra piece of evidence for his case. Now Jacquet goes on about different ways to use shaming to benefit society and how it will help shape the future. An example that was in the story explains how shaming a fisherman who is fishing in a marine protected area can help sanction laws to prevent further damage. Shame can help in many ways, but there is a particular way shame must be used to help rather than having a negative connotation to it. Jacquet wants to educate others that shaming is not only for the bad but can help enforce basic standards.
An interesting quote by author and professor Brene Brown states, Shame corrodes the very part of us that believes we are capable of change, (Brown 88). This is an aspect most could not comprehend because it is not something one must experience but feel. The earliest signs of shame upon one another date back to the old ages when there was an abundance of hierarchical statuses, and throughout all the changes, shame is still present to shape the world. The two stories both convey a message about shaming and the endless possibilities of interpretations that allows for change. Both stories also have differences such as Ronson saying how the shame Sacco received was not justifiable and how Jacquets reasonings were about how shame can be put to use. Shaming can be used in multiple ways. It is on the person to decide whether it is good or bad. The two authors have their views and ways to articulate what they want to hear or see. Overall, these similarities and differences all play a part in how the story is structured.
How one feels about shaming is based upon their own decisions and how they react towards it. If an effort is put forth to examine a thought, the outcome will most likely come through naturally, and that will base ones opinion. Although this exact subject can be quite profound, there are remnants of history that mirrors the nature of humans who need to refresh their thoughts.